The OrangeLantern Hat is a unobtainable hat in the PFS store. It's just a carved pumpkin.
The humble pumpkin head. Fell out of favour, this one. Back in my days, this was the creme de le creme of costumes. Everywhere there were people wearing poorly shaped pumpkin heads. And people didn't mind.
Now we are on a financial budget. Hats like the PaperScrub Hat are now regarded the best hats. Because seriously, whats more frightening then some beady eyes?